Self-Immolation A Growing Trend in Afghan Women

In Afghanistan, a growing number of women, primarily aged 10-40, attempt to flee lives of hopelessness and despair by setting themselves on fire.

It is difficult to accurately estimate the number of Afghan women and girls who attempt to kill themselves with petrol and a match. Anywhere from one hundred to several hundred cases of self-immolation have been reported each year since 2002. A New York Times article reports that in 2004 the Afghan Independent Human Rights Commission recorded 40 cases in six months in the city of Herat alone. These reported numbers are exceptionally low, however, because families often hide the incident or try to lie about the method of death.

Reported cases are almost entirely of those who survive, even briefly, and find themselves being treated in a local burn unit. Yet even these women often attempt to lie about their wounds, insisting the incident was accidental. The staff at the burn unit in Herat's Regional Medical Center have learned to discern the truth. Fuel-soaked clothing and little evidence of an attempt to stifle flames strongly point to self-infliction. Dr. Ghafar Bawar, a plastic surgeon who consults at the unit, explains

"When an accident happens, they try to stop it. In self-inflicted burns, a high percentage of the body surface area is affected. When it is more than 40 per cent of body surface area burnt . . . it's usually self-inflicted."

For many western readers, it's hard to understand what would drive these women, many of them teens, to commit such a desperate and agonizing act. It's important to recognize Afghanistan's deep-seated culture of female oppression and the utter lack of options perceived by most women.

Many Afghan women, especially in rural villages, live in a state of near slavery. They are kept uneducated and have little or no control over the most basic aspects of their lives.

Forced into marriage as a young teen, (the youngest reported case of self-immolation was a nine year old child), to a man possibly decades older, an Afghan girl must obey not only her new husband but any of his male or female relatives. She endures daily beatings and other, often sexual, abuses. She cannot read or write and has been prohibited from learning a valuable skill or trade. All she knows of the world is what she has been told, and what she is told cultivates hopelessness, humiliation, and the constant threat of violence. Even her own voice is useless to her. If she speaks out she earns only ridicule or further punishment.

Where can she turn? A few girls are lucky enough to learn of a shelter for abused women and child brides, though even fewer are able to escape. Illiterate and isolated, most women have no idea that any escape is possible. In their minds, they have nothing.

No courts, no police, no divorce, no justice, no escape.

When the Taliban were toppled and Hamid Karzai took power at the end of 2001, it seemed Afghan women would enjoy a life of more freedom and stability. Unfortunately, many women live under nearly the same oppression, humiliation, and violence that they suffered under the Taliban.

Let's take a closer look at the reality of life for most Afghan women, shaped drastically by recent Taliban rule and related gender beliefs which, for too many, still linger.

Life Under the Taliban

The Taliban ruled Afghanistan, through continued insurgency and civil war, from 1996 until nearly 2002.

Under Taliban rule, Afghan women were oppressed in literally every aspect of their lives. In what has been referred to as gender apartheid, women were placed under house arrest, denied the ability to work or gain an education, and required to shield themselves from all males except very close relatives. The windows of her home were painted black, lest an innocently passing male catch a forbidden glimpse, and she could not leave her home at all unless escorted by a close male relative and sheathed in full burqa. When outside the home, she was careful to both speak and step softly, lest her presence be seductively audible to strange males.

Any woman who had lost all male relatives in the years of ongoing conflict was literally trapped in her home.

Unable to seek medical treatment from doctors who, under Taliban rule, were necessarily all male, women frequently died of treatable ailments.

Anyone caught defying the new laws risked public beating and execution. Speaking too loudly or or inadvertently flashing an ankle or wrist earned a woman a public lashing. Women caught unattended outside their homes, assumed to be attempting to flee, were often stoned to death. Women in the presence of a non-related male were charged with adultery and hanged.

Today...

In 2002, when the Taliban lost control of Afghanistan's central government, the lives of many Afghan women brightened. For the most part, educated, urban women returned to work or school and as their country worked to rebuild itself, they strove to reclaim their lives.

Unfortunately, Afghan women in poor, rural areas, continue to live under the same oppression and abuse as before. While Taliban law is no longer in effect, many rural areas are governed by tribal law, which remains uninfluenced by the Afghan government. In many territories, warlords rule with impunity and throughout the nation societal norms give males full dominance over women, who are treated with violence and contempt on a daily basis.

Three women initially held positions in President Kazai's cabinet, however all have since been replaced by males, including the Minister of Women's Affairs. A 2006 article in the Christian Science Monitor explains

Women's inclusion in Afghanistan's government, which the international community has been using as an indicator of democratic progress, is actually regressing. The interim Supreme Court has consistently sided with conservatives [...] It has issued bans on women singing on television... and upheld the marriage of a 9-year-old girl, even though Afghan law sets marriageable age at 16.

Afghan women are repeatedly denied equal access to legal representation and due process. Nearly 80 percent of the women in prison have been convicted of zina, engaging in sexual activity outside marriage. But the majority of those convicted were simply trying to escape domestic abuse and seek refuge outside their oppressive households.

The reality of life for many rural Afghan women is one of utter helplessness. Once forced into marriage, an Afghan female loses the ability to determine what she does, or where she goes, in some cases ever. Daily beatings are common, as are psychological humiliation and degradation. Rape perpetrated by a husband is not considered abnormal, let alone a crime.

Afghanistan's groundbreaking 2004 presidential election was a passing irrelevance for most Afghan women.  According to a 2007 UNIFEM fact sheet,

• 87% of Afghans believed that a woman needed  a male relatives authorization to vote.
• 35% of women believed they would not have permission to vote.
• 18% of men admitted they would not allow they wives to vote.

 

Additionally,

• 70-80% of Afghan women  face forced marriages
• 57% of Afghan girls are married before the legal marriage age of sixteen.

Why Fire?

Although self-immolation seems to be one of the most abhorrent choices for suicide, it is, for many, the only choice. Although some find access to poisons, most have no way of going outside the home for any needed materials. Other available options, such as wrist cutting or hanging, are not fool-proof enough for their intentions. Fire, they believe, is absolute.

Medica Modiale, an organization dedicated to aiding women in war zones and areas of crisis, conducted the first report on self-immolation in Afghan women. They found:

Self-immolation as a method of committing suicide is so frequent because women feel they have no alternative. They can never leave the house and have no access to medicaments. However, there is flammable material in contrast in every kitchen.

Medica Modiale's  Nabila Wafiq told the Washington Post

"When we asked most people why they committed self-immolation, they said that when they take pills, they don't die, but when they commit self-immolation they believe they will die, 100 percent."

Additionally, women are drawn to fire by the opportunity for retribution it presents. An overwhelming atmosphere of shame and dishonor surround the families of those who choose to who self-immolate. This actually contributes to the death-rate of these suicide attempts, as most women die because they are not immediately taken to the hospital, or not taken at all.

The fact that it is difficult to lie about the method of death, often leaves abusive families with an intended stigma. Unfortunately, this motive backfires on a woman who survives. The shame of her act often means total isolation and neglect.

Wafiq also asserts that the trend is growing, in part, because of news reports of suicide by self-immolation, which fail to mention the tortured survivors of the act, or those who take agonizing days to finally die.

Journalist Sharmeen Obaid Chinoy, speaking to RAWA (The Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan) about "Lifting the Veil", her documentary on  the experiences of Afghan women, explains

There are many ways to die – you can take poison or jump in a river. But I think that if those women had died in that way, it would have been easy for the men of the family to cover it up, saying she had a heart attack, or she fell down or something.

But if you pour kerosene on yourself and you light a match, you're making a statement. You're saying look at me, I am in pain, I am in misery, I am not going to die quietly, I am making a point.

In Their Words...

17-year old Fazela:

"My name is Fazela. On that particular day when I burned myself, my husband -- who is also my cousin -- had a fight with me," she recalls. "He beat me. And after I was beaten, I poured kerosene over myself. Then I lit myself on fire. Before this, I really wanted to leave this house. But he took my burqa and did not let me go outside of the house. Now I really regret that I burned myself."

-- Radio Free Europe RadioLiberty

16-year old survivor describes the moments leading up to her self-immolation

"When he did not have access to heroin and narcotics, he tortured me. After midnight he would hit me. That night he hit me and hit my head. Blood was coming from my nose. I asked him why he was doing it and he hit me even more."

-- BBC News 11/15/06

How You Can Help

Donate to the Afghan Women's Mission and you can specify how you want your dollars spent - general fund, education, awareness, etc... They also have pledge program, volunteer info, and more...

The Feminist Majority Foundation runs a campaign entitled Help Afghan Women. They make it quick and easy to petition the US government, spread the word to friends and colleagues, join an action team, and of course, donate.

RAWA has a range of specific donation needs - used digital cameras, school supplies, medical supplies. They also have all sorts of other ideas of how you can help - from translating articles to arranging photo exhibits. Of course you can always write awareness letters or just send some cash! Check it out.

Comments

[Len Avarfon]

The best way we can help? Support our government when our government sends in troops to destroy the Taliban and Al Queda. Donating money to some organization ain't gonna do squat. Those bastards need to be killed.

[Nike Jordan]

As empty vessels make the loudest sound, so they that have least with are the greatest babblers. Do you think so?

[LUCIUS TORE DANNEBRO]

ISLAM HAS TO GO AND DISSAPEARE AND MAKE WAY FOR SOMETHING NEW, THE HOLY KORAN AND PROPHET MOHAMMAD WAS DIVINE ORIGINALLY BUT NOW AFTER APRX. 1500 YEARS IT HAVE TURN INTO EVIL AND SATANISM,

THE KORAN WAS TOTALLY DIFFERENT INTERPRETED BY MOHAMMAD THEN WHAT THE MULLAS AND THE TALIBAN DOES O DAY: THEY READ THE KORAN AS SATAN READS THE BIBLE. MAY IMAM-MAHDI/CHRIST/MESSIAHS/BOHDISATVAN (IT IS THE SAME DIVINE MESSENGER) STEP FORWARD AND RENEW OUR WORLD WITH HIS DIVINE LOVE AND COMPASSION. KIND REGARDS MR DANNEBRO.

[Fatimamohammadi]

It isn't a part of Islam for men to rule the world and I know this because I am a female afghani and my parents will not force me to marry anyone. The Taliban are not real Muslims. These are the believes of a Muslim
There is one god
God is forgiving and almighty
There will be a judgement day
There are prophets
One day our savior will come

Please understand that muslims are not bad people those people that kill others and say that it is a Muslim believe are not real muslMs because in the Quran it doesn't say to kill innocent people it says killing Inocent people is a sin
Thank you for read hope this helped you understand

[MarinEddy]

@Len Avarfon. I've fought in Afghanistan for quite a few years and I can tell you that war, and killing doesn't change anything, not one bit. it's violence what leads to more crap! and one more thing for everybody to know, violence against women isn't part of Afghan culture, not at all. Afghans are the most courageous and most decent people I've ever met.

[pure boy]

lolz , starting from 911 wtc incident till today usa has killed billions of muslims and other humans for its own national interest , 911 was basically planned for looting the oil and resources of the muslims countries , even the animals today know this fact that 911 incident was all inside job , bi da way what happened to wtc 7th building no plane hit that building even then it came to earth like a biscuit , even the intellectuals and engineers and architects of usa have accepted and came to this fact 100% sure that wtc buildings were destroyed throughhhhhh CONTROLLED DEMOLITION , THE TALIBAN's are the combined production of USA and PAKISTAN army general ziaul haq (which was lately killed by usa itself in a plane crashed planned by usa itself killing its own generals also in that plane ) coming to iraq , there was no taliban in iraq , usa attacked iraq for keeping the biological weapons , even without confirming it later on after the atttack it was proved that there was nothing found as biological weapons , even usa government agencies have admitted that attack on iraq was a mistake even then since 2003 till today dec 2011 usa is in iraq , killing its people destroyed its economy totally and since 2003 every day usa is looting billions of dollars of oil from iraq and pumping into usa , since 2003 till today u cannot even imagine that trillions of dollars i mean u cannot even calculate that much oil has beeen looted stealed by usa from iraq and pumped into usa , my dear all usa is 100 % more cruel and against humanity than the pharaoahs of egypt in prophet moses time and than the roman empire , usa has crossed the limits of humanity since the 911 incident happened , my dear all theres so much to say but i dont have time much , u can search all the facts on the internet any thing u want to know , but U have to be a neutral person while searching and truth seeker than u will get to the truth otherwise not .